As OnDeck’s Stock Hits Record Low, Is There a Renewed Confidence in the Broker Channel?
November 6, 2016
OnDeck traded below $4 on Friday, a new all-time low that came in the wake of the company’s earnings announcement just the day before. Apparently, the company’s record-breaking $613 million in quarterly originations was not the assurance that investors were looking for.
Their report showed that more of the company’s loans are staying on their balance sheet and notably, there’s been an increase in the percentage of loans sourced from brokers. 27% of the dollars originated in Q3 came from brokers versus only 24.5% during the same period last year. Meanwhile, the raw number of loans originated by brokers is up from 18.6% to 20.2% in Q3 year-over-year. These are still substantially lower than previous years. For instance, brokers originated 41.4% of dollars in 2014, 56.54% in 2013 and 75.1% in 2012.
OnDeck refers to brokers as “funding advisors” in their reports, with company CEO Noah Breslow noting that this channel has grown 40% year-over-year, almost twice as fast as their direct and strategic channels. Analysts took note and Brian Fitzgerald from Jefferies asked why this was occurring on the morning call. Breslow responded by saying that it wasn’t due to any intentional reallocation of resources among the channels.
“So at any given quarter you may see a push/pull on the relative growth rates of the channel but I would say that we’re not sort of allocating resources or dollars between channels and the channels really are competing for resources internally. So I think the dynamic in funding advisors frankly, is a positive. We took that channel down last year, we did a pretty aggressive recertification. So we’re working with a lot fewer partners than we did a while back and on the flip side, those partners are higher quality and we’re seeing better originations now from them; and we’ve really optimized our conversion rates with a number of those partners. So we feel we feel pretty good about that.”
Also discussed on the call was OnDeck’s partnership with Barbara Corcoran, in which it was said that the company is sending out direct mail using her name and likeness to promote the company. Her TV commercials have already been making the rounds.
And just as signing on Shark Tank stars as partners probably doesn’t come cheap, Breslow suggested that the industry competition had really been narrowed down to the players who had already made hundreds of millions of dollars in loans.
“I think it’s fair to say that the very early stage start-ups or the subscale players are increasingly having a little bit more trouble competing, so we are seeing the preponderance of some of the marketing activity coming from folks who are a little bit larger in scale. And my sense is that continues and that’s going to consistent with the overall trends that people have seen. So the folks who are buying marketing at this point are folks who have loaned hundreds of millions of dollars as opposed to tens of millions of dollars, and I think the VC environment for these types of companies remains pretty challenging.”
Brief: Cross River Bank Raises $28 Million in Equity
November 1, 2016
New Jersey-based Cross River Bank, a marketplace lending partner bank, secured $28 million in equity, led by Boston-based investment firm Battery Ventures, along with Silicon Valley venture capital firms Andreessen Horowitz and Ribbit Capital.
The capital will be used to expand the bank’s technology and product-development teams, invest in compliance infrastructure and plan new business lines to the online lending industry. Battery General Partner Scott Tobin will also join the Cross River board of directors.
Cross River originated over $2.4 billion loans in 2015 and partners with over 15 online lenders including Affirm, Borrowers First, Marlette Funding, Rocket Loans and Upstart.
Brief: Lendio Raises $20 million for Growth Marketing
October 25, 2016
Salt Lake City-based loan marketplace Lendio raised $20 million in new funding through a round led by Comcast Ventures and Stereo Capital. Other participants included Napier Park, Blumberg Capital, Tribeca Venture Partners and North Hill Ventures, all of whom were exiting investors. Lendio plans to use the funds towards growth marketing.
“Over the past year, we’ve been busy testing new customer acquisition strategies. With this new round of capital, we now have the resources to launch these exciting new initiatives that will help us to expand our brand awareness and help small businesses find the best loan for any situation,” said Lendio CEO Brock Blake.
Lendio is a loan marketplace that has done partnerships right. The company’s three lucrative deals with American Express, GoDaddy and Staples fueled $63 million in Q3 funding. Last month, the company added Detroit-based working capital financing company Supplier Success to its platform, to improve capital access to businesses owned by minority and women owners.
“Lendio’s success securing meaningful partnerships and impressive year-over-year growth shows the company is poised to go big,” said Dave Zilberman, managing director of Comcast Ventures, who will join Lendio’s board of directors as part of the transaction.
Expansion Capital Group Announces New Executive Management Team
October 25, 2016SIOUX FALLS, S.D., October 25, 2016 – Expansion Capital Group (ECG), a provider of small business loans, is pleased to announce several changes to its executive management team.
Effective immediately, Mr. Vincent Ney (ECG’s majority shareholder) is CEO and will focus on further developing the foundation built by the Expansion Capital team. In addition to an impressive combination of leadership and operational experience, Mr. Ney brings a passion for building financial services businesses with a focus on meeting the needs of its strategic partners and its customers. Most recently, he was involved in the online consumer lending sector where he was instrumental in building a business to $100 million in revenue.
As part of Mr. Ney’s early initiatives, Expansion Capital Group has begun testing and implementing new loan term and pricing options to provide broader and more advantageous solutions for borrowers.
Additionally, Mr. Marc Helman has joined Expansion Capital Group as Director of Strategic Partnerships. In this role, Mr. Helman is responsible for driving originations across the Company’s Funding Partner and Partnership channels. Before joining ECG, Mr. Helman spent over ten years in investment banking and venture capital, providing financing to both private and publicly traded small businesses. Mr. Helman stated, “I am incredibly excited to join Expansion Capital Group’s growing team. As our product offerings and platform continue to expand, we look forward to serving the capital needs of a wider variety of small businesses.”
Mr. Ney and Mr. Helman add to other members of the executive team that joined earlier in 2016. Mr. Herk Christie joined ECG’s operations team in March after experience and tenure with Resurgent Capital Services and Capital One. Mr. Tim Mages joined in February as CFO to assist ECG with its financial analysis and Capital Markets initiatives.
Dusty Wasmund, ECG’s VP of Business Development and Channel Partnerships, stated “During the past six months, ECG has broadened its executive management team to build a sustainable business that enables small business owners to access capital quickly to capitalize on their objectives. Our combined team brings a variety of experiences and perspectives to better serve our customer’s needs. This team has collaborated extensively during the past 60 days to strategically bring two new product innovations to market, which provide our borrowers greater financing options tailored to their specific needs. I am very excited about our revised positioning and look forward to working with many of our strategic partners during 2017 as we continue to grow our platform.”
As part of these changes, ECG also recently executed a partial equity recapitalization by ECG’s existing two family office investors. This additional equity, along with its $25 million credit facility closed in partnership with Northlight Financial and Bastion Management during the fourth quarter of 2015, provides ECG with enhanced capital resources to facilitate future growth. With this additional equity base and more flexible product alternatives, ECG will look to significantly expand its origination partners and loan volume.
About Expansion Capital Group:
Since 2013, Expansion Capital Group has provided over 5,000 small businesses with capital exceeding $130 million. Expansion Capital Group has developed a platform based on data aggregation and predictive modeling, which enables it to service this target market cost-effectively. Expansion Capital Group uses a broad array of both traditional and nontraditional data sources to predict individual performance and cash flow of each small business.
For general inquiries, please contact:
Tim Mages
CFO
(605) 877-3910
For sales, lead generation, or channel partner inquiries, please contact:
Mr. Dusty Wasmund
VP of Sales and Channel Partnerships
(605) 351-5833
Mr. Marc Helman
Director of Strategic Partnerships
(605) 681-6400
Bizfi Appoints Alternative Finance and Payments Veteran John Donovan as CEO
October 24, 2016
New York – October 24, 2016 – Bizfi (www.bizfi.com), a leading fintech company with a platform that combines aggregation, funding and a marketplace for small businesses, announced its board of directors has appointed John Donovan as the Company’s chief executive officer (CEO). Donovan is a 30-year veteran in the payments and alternative finance industry serving both small businesses and consumers.
Over the course of his career, Donovan helped pave the way for the development of the fintech and alternative finance industry. Having worked for nearly two decades with MasterCard, Donovan was integral to conceiving and developing new products, launching a global card program and growing the Company’s global electronic payments offerings. As one of the founding employees of Lending Club, Donovan helped create the direct-to-consumer fintech industry that has transformed the way consumers and financial institutions interact with one another. During his tenure at Lending Club, he held various roles including chief operating officer, board member and executive vice president of corporate development.
“Bizfi is transforming the way small businesses are accessing growth and working capital. John Donovan brings a unique combination of industry-related expertise, strategic vision and proven management experience which will accelerate this transformation and further enhance our market-leading position in the fintech space,” said Tom Breitling, Bizfi Chairman.
“I have known the Bizfi team for many years and have been extremely impressed with the market presence the company has established in the fintech space,” said John Donovan. “I have spent my career building and operating companies, conceptualizing new products and increasing shareholder value. It is clear that the Bizfi team have built the single best way for small businesses to access capital in a quick, frictionless and simple way.”
With originations growing over 35% over the past year, Bizfi continues to demonstrate record volumes, and is on track to approach nearly $600 million of fundings this year, highlighting the strength and scalability of the overall platform and the company’s leading position in the fintech industry.
Since its creation in 2005, Bizfi has provided more than $1.9 billion in capital to more than 33,000 small business owners. Earlier this year, the Company announced partnerships with Western Independent Bankers (WIB) and the National Directory of Registered Tax Return Preparers & Professionals (PTIN). These partnerships are providing hundreds of thousands of small business owners across the country with access to financing through the Bizfi platform in addition to the ability to visit Bizfi.com, the Company’s lending marketplace.
About Bizfi
Bizfi is the premier fintech company combining aggregation, funding and a participation marketplace on a single platform for small businesses. Founded in 2005, Bizfi and its family of companies have provided in excess of $1.9 billion in financing to more than 33,000 small businesses in a wide variety of industries across the United States.
Bizfi’s connected marketplace instantly provides multiple funding options and real-time pre-approvals to businesses from a wide variety of funding partners. Bizfi’s funding options include short-term financing, franchise financing, lines of credit, equipment financing, medical financing, invoice financing, medium-term loans and long-term loans guaranteed by the U.S. Small Business Administration. The Bizfi API provides a turnkey white label or co-branded solution that easily allows strategic partners to access the Bizfi engine and present their clients with financial offers from Bizfi lenders all while maintaining their customer’s user experience. A process that once took hours, now takes minutes.
Media Contact:
Abbie Sheridan / Kenneth Cousins
KCSA Strategic Communications
asheridan@kcsa.com / kcousins@kcsa.com
212-896-1207 / 212-896-1254
Bizfi Sales:
855-462-4934
bizfisales@bizfi.com
CFPB Rebuts its Unconstitutionality
October 21, 2016
The CFPB does not agree with the D.C. Circuit’s ruling that its leadership structure is unconstitutional, according to a reply filed in a separate case in the District of North Dakota. Believing itself constitutionally exempt from oversight by the President of the United States and any checks on its power whatsoever, the CFPB argued that the D.C. Circuit “based its decision on (a) the lack of sufficient historical precedent for the Bureau’s structure, and (b) a policy judgment that multi-member commissions are superior to single agency heads.”
It also suggested that it will be appealing the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Remarkably, the D.C. Circuit Court’s ruling did not even call for the CFPB to be dismantled or have its funding reassigned to Congress, but instead ordered that it fall into line with the structure of other executive agencies where a reasonable system of checks and balances be implemented at the top. As originally created, CFPB Director Cordray was granted unilateral power that neither his agency colleagues or the President of the United States could check. Now, the CFPB appears unwilling to cede such authority.
“The CFPB’s concentration of enormous executive power in a single, unaccountable, unchecked Director not only departs from settled historical practice, but also poses a far greater risk of arbitrary decision-making and abuse of power, and a far greater threat to individual liberty, than does a multi-member independent agency,” the D.C. Circuit Court asserted.
Despite that, in CFPB v. Intercept Corporation, et al., the CFPB argued that “decision was wrongly decided and is not likely to withstand further review.”
Some Alternative Funders See Pot As Next Big Market Opportunity
October 17, 2016
For some funders, marijuana is not just about sewing their wild oats. Rather, they see the business potential of being early to what’s expected to be a highly profitable and long-lasting party.
Indeed, for the right type of funder, doling out money to marijuana-related businesses is a promising market—certainly in the short term because these companies are so capital-starved. Because marijuana is still classified by the feds as an illegal drug, many related businesses can’t even get a bank account much less access to bank loans or more traditional funding. Many alternative funders are also unwilling to lend to marijuana-related businesses, which has left a significant void that’s beginning to be filled by opportunistic private equity investors, venture capitalists and others.
Meanwhile, rapidly shifting public opinion and state-centered initiatives bode well for what many estimate is a multi-billion dollar market. Indeed, industry watchers say marijuana funding will eventually be an even stronger niche than lending to alcohol producers, tobacco companies or pharmaceuticals because of all the ancillary business opportunities related to medical marijuana use.
“I think it’s probably the biggest opportunity we’ve seen since the Internet,” says Steve Gormley, managing partner and chief executive at Seventh Point LLC, a Norwalk, Connecticut-based private equity firm that invests in the cannabis industry. “Consumption continues to grow and demand is there,” he notes.
Despite shifting public opinion, legalized marijuana use is still quite controversial. So, all things considered, it takes a particularly thick-skinned funding company—one that has no moral objectives to marijuana and is also willing to accept a significant amount of legal, business and reputational risk—to throw its hat in the ring.
One of the biggest challenges keeping banks and many mainstream funders at bay is that cannabis remains illegal under law. Despite numerous attempts by proponents to scrap marijuana’s outlaw status, the DEA recently dealt out a significant blow by opting to maintain the status quo. This means that for the foreseeable future marijuana remains a Schedule I drug, on par with LSD and heroin, and as a result many lenders will choose to remain on the sidelines for now.
It remains promising, however, that over the past several years, the federal government has taken a more laissez-faire approach, giving individual states the authority to decide how they will deal with legalizing marijuana use. Forty-two states, the District of Columbia, and the U.S. territories of Puerto Rico and Guam have adopted laws recognizing marijuana’s medical value, according to the Marijuana Policy Project, an advocacy group. Four states—Alaska, Washington, Oregon, and Colorado—as well as the District of Columbia have gone even further. They allow the recreational use of marijuana for adults, with certain restrictions. Meanwhile, marijuana initiatives are on the November ballot in numerous states.
As these changes have percolated, forward-thinking alternative funders have been dipping their toes in the market—getting an early start on a market that’s hungrily looking for growth capital. “The last couple years there have been fewer investors than capital needed, but we believe that tide is changing,” says Morgan Paxhia, managing director and chief investor of Poseidon Asset Management LLC in San Francisco, an investment management company founded in 2013 to invest exclusively in the cannabis industry.
Paxhia says he’s starting to see more venture capitalists, lease-finance companies and private equity investors willing to provide liquidity to marijuana-based companies that are seeking to grow. The short-term cash advance marketplace, however, is not there yet. The challenge is finding funders willing to do the business with them.
“The people that are building these businesses have to always be worried about their cash. It’s not a given that they’ll get new additional investment,” Paxhia says. “Most people are quick to brush it aside. They won’t give it a minute to take a serious look at it and understand that it is already a multi-billion dollar market growing at 30 percent annualized for the next several years,”
A QUIETLY GROWING INDUSTRY
There are a number of private investors and venture capitalists who have spent the last several years researching and ramping up to invest in what they see as a goldmine of business opportunities. Many of these companies aren’t shy about publicly expressing their support for change.
“We see this as an opportunity of a lifetime to witness a societal change and we want to be a part of it,” says Paxhia who together with his sister runs a $10 million investment fund.
At the same time, there are also some alternative funders who dabble in this space and won’t discuss it publicly—partly because of the perceived stigma and partly out of concern that their financial backers won’t approve. To cover themselves, some are only willing to deal with companies that have hard assets. Often times the rates they offer are much higher than businesses in other industries with comparable financials would pay.
Andrew Vanam, founder of Rx Capital Funding LLC, an ISO in Norwalk, Connecticut, who focuses on the healthcare and medical industry, has helped a handful of few marijuana-related businesses get funding in the past few years and would love to help facilitate more deals. But he says it’s extremely difficult to find lenders that are willing to fund cannabis-related businesses as well as offer reasonable rates. Many of the files he generates in the cannabis space have incredible financials, positive cash flow, and month-on-month growth. However, lenders still treat these businesses as high-risk and offer rates so high it’s not even worth bringing back to a client. Instead, “they are taking hard money loans from private investors that put these cash advance offers to shame,” he says.
ASSESSING THE RISKS
Certainly there are risks to funding marijuana businesses. In Colorado—one of the first states to legalize the recreational use of marijuana—values are getting lofty, and people are overpaying for properties that house marijuana-related businesses, notes Glen Weinberg, a partner in Fairview Commercial Lending, a hard-money lender with offices in Atlanta and Evergreen, Colorado.
Weinberg has financed between 75 and 100 commercial real estate loans where marijuana businesses were involved, but says recently he’s shied away. “I’m not comfortable with the valuations at a lot of these marijuana properties,” he says.
Even investors who are bullish on the space urge caution. “If you’re in a [nationwide] market that is growing at about 64 percent per year, that rising tide floats all boats, but there’s a lot of risk, so you have to be careful,” says Chet Billingsley, chief executive of Mentor Capital Inc., a public operating company in Ramona, California, which acquires and provides liquidity for medical and social use cannabis companies.
Billingsley says he has learned some hard lessons through his dealings with about nine marijuana-related companies. For example, he recently won a court judgment against a company that Mentor had supplied with millions of dollars in cash and stock. The company later balked at the terms of the deal and tried to renege, but Mentor ultimately prevailed in court. Still, Billingsley says Mentor went through many unnecessary hassles and racked up $300k in legal costs over the course of its two-and-a-half-year legal battle.
Many business owners in the marijuana space started out during a period when it w as completely illegal. Often these companies march to the beat of their own drum; to protect themselves, lenders need to do more than offer a standard funding contract and hope for the best, Billingsley says.
“The contract has to be solid and it has to be explained in detail to the marijuana operator who is often not sophisticated with regard to contracts.” If you leave things open to interpretation, you’re likely to end up in court, where anything can happen, he cautions.
Companies that fund cannabis businesses say they have very extensive vetting processes—so much so that they turn away a good portion of requests. Jeffrey Howard, managing partner of Salveo Capital in Chicago, says about two-thirds of the companies that come across his desk don’t make it past the company’s initial criteria. “We see a ton of companies and business plans from companies seeking capital to raise money,” he says. “We are going to be very selective about who we invest in and how much.”
Gormley, of Seventh Point, leverages all the same resources he would if he were buying any retail or production manufacturing outfit. He does extremely invasive vetting of the individuals involved and uses private detectives to help.
It many cases it comes down to the business’s management team, according to Paxhia of Poseidon Asset Management. “All the businesses are very early-stage and most companies have a very short track record, so you have to place a greater emphasis on the people,” he says.
OPPORTUNITIES ABOUND
Despite the risks, funders that work in the marijuana space say they are filling an important need by providing capital to marijuana-related businesses. For Gormley of Seventh Point, it’s a calculated risk in an area he’s been following for quite some time. “How often do you get to be part of history, and how often do you get to participate in a burgeoning market?” he says.
Industry participants stress the many funding opportunities aside from companies that cultivate and distribute the plant. Indeed, there are many ancillary businesses that provide products and services geared towards patients and cannabis users without having anything to do with the actual plant.
Howard of Salveo Capital, says his company is gearing up to provide private equity and venture capital to several marijuana-related businesses through its Salveo Fund I and will only make select investments into companies that “touch the plant.” The goal is to eventually have $25 million of committed capital to invest in multiple early-stage companies that offer ancillary products and services to the marijuana industry. “We think there’s more exciting opportunities than ‘touch the plant’ investments,” he says.
Crowdfunding platforms are another avenue for companies in the marijuana space. This type of funding hasn’t yet been utilized to its full potential, industry watchers say.
Eaze Solutions, a San Francisco-based provider of technology that optimizes medical marijuana delivery, is one example of a company that turned to crowdfunding. It raised part of a $1.5 million infusion to fund its expansion via the crowdfunding site AngelList in 2014. Loto Labs, in Redwood City, California, is another example. It raised more than $220k via Indiegogo to fund production of its Evoke vaporizer. There’s also CannaFundr, an online investment marketplace for companies in the cannabis industry to gain access to capital.
Seth Yakatan, co-founder of Katan Associates in Hermosa Beach, California, suggests that crowdfunding will become more of an option for certain types of cannabis based companies, specifically those that aren’t as closely tied to the actual production of the plant. “Until federal regulations change, it’s going to be hard to raise money for an entity where you are actively engaged in the cultivation, distribution or sales of a product that’s federally illegal,” says Yakatan, whose company invests in and advises cannabis-related companies that have a biotech or pharmaceutical orientation.
Because laws on legalized marijuana are still in limbo, industry watchers say the market is still many years away from being mainstream. “Public perception will be similar to alcohol in 10 years from now,” predicts Weinberg of Fairview Commercial Lending, adding that he expects banks to enter the funding arena in five to 10 years.
In the meantime, alternative funders who can stomach risk continue to pave the path for others. Howard of Salveo Capital expects private equity investors, venture capitalists and other alternative players to continue playing a big role in getting the nascent industry off the ground.
“I strongly believe that in the interim there’s a significant advantage for players like us to be funding and to be in on the ground floor of this industry before it changes,” Howard says.
Indeed, many alternative funders believe the potential upside significantly outweighs possible negative consequences. “The perceived risk at this point is far greater than the actual risk,” says Paxhia of Poseidon Asset Management.
Remember When? Funders Talk About Their First Deals
October 14, 2016
It’s hard to forget the firsts, especially first deals — they set precedents, lay down the groundwork for policies and establish a starting point for legacy.
For funders and lenders, their first deal can be significant in establishing client relations, setting priorities for credit policies and as we found out, teaching them valuable lessons.
First Steps..Baby Steps
John D’Amico’s first bet was a small cafe in Carmel, Indiana that his company GRP Funding advanced $25,000 to, eight years ago. Reviewed on credit card sales, GRP looked at the business’ cash flow and deemed it a good risk to take, D’Amico recollected.
“That business model seems so far and long ago,” he said. “OnDeck was not a company at that point and loan products were not talked about. It was only advances.”
Would he still feel confident doing the same deal today? “Yes, that deal is still there to be had today. But you want to make sure that you’re not stacked.”
#LifeLessons: Don’t get comfortable, stay updated with the times and evolve and keep the credit risk policies fresh.
Small Can Be Significant
The first check, Jersey City-based World Business Leaders cut was for $7,000, back in 2011.
Chief revenue officer, Alex Gemici recalled that it was an African arts store run by a woman in Virginia Beach who paid back the loan in full and came back three months later for an additional loan of $12,000.
“We believed her story and went by our lending policy and the deal fit the bill.”
#LifeLessons: We could make a big difference even with a small loan.
Not All Firsts Are Good
But not everyone has a smooth start. For New York City-based company, Cardinal Equity, the first deal was a bump on the road.
The auto dealership in New Jersey that it advanced $250,000 to in 2011 defaulted on the second renewal. Although Arty Bujan, managing member at Cardinal Equity still thinks auto dealerships are a “nightmare,” his company still funds them but with very strict scrutiny, looking for ones with a steady revenue stream and a good amount of time in the business.
#LifeLessons: There’s always risk





























